So does the "sweet wine can be great" apply only to German Riesling? Absolutely not. Apply the same thinking to any wine with residual sugar. If it is balanced, it can be good. Other German wines, Austrian wines, some Loire wines such as Vouvray, some sparkling wines including some Champagnes, Alsatian wines and others can all have some residual sugar that is balanced.
Finally, there is an entire category of wine that we shouldn't lump in here. Dessert style wines are wines that are meant to be quite sweet, ranging from moderately sweet to downright sticky. Wines like Port, Madeira, Trockenbeerenauslese from Germany, Eiswein (or Icewine), Sauternes, Loire Moelleux, Sélection de Grains Nobles from Alsace, Tokaji (pronounced Tokay) from Hungary and other styles of wine are meant to be very sweet and to be drunk as a dessert (or occasionally as an an accompaniment to certain dishes such as foie gras). These wines can be very serious wines deserving of every wine lover's attention. The key, again, is having enough balancing structure, acid, tannin, and/or minerality, to stand up to the sweetness so that it is balanced.
So don't immediately dismiss a wine because it has some sweetness. Evaluate it like you would any other wine. Is it complex? Does it taste good? How is the mouthfeel? The finish? And most importantly, is it balanced?
The Poor Man's Guide's
|Zero Stars||A wine I don't particularly recommend.|
|Well made, simple and tasty wines that I recommend.|
|Excellent quality. Worth an extra effort to search out and enjoy.|
|Outstanding wine of the highest caliber.|
|Either a wine that is close to deserving a higher score or a wine that may not be showing that much but with the potential to move up in quality with further aging. A young wine that may be closed up or shows potential for significant improvement. Assuming it opens and improves with additional age, it may merit a higher rating.|
|???||Flawed bottles or wines that are difficult to assess for any number of reasons. Judgement reserved.|
|A. Robert Grand Cru
Cuvée de Réserve
Blanc de Blancs
|This is a small Champagne grower located in Le Mesnil sur Oger. I had been somewhat disappointed by a recent Cuvée Séduction that I had, feeling it had a bit too much sweetness from dosage, making it a bit flabby. While it was complex and had a lovely caressing texture, I felt it needed a bit more vibrancy. So I approached this blanc de blanc (100% Chardonnay) with a bit of caution. I needn't have worried. This wine is lovely and better balanced in my opinion. Complex aromas have a nuttiness, like marzipan, but with intriguing spicy notes reminiscent of cumin and allspice. The nice thing is that the flavors have a bright attack that wakes up your palate and makes you take notice of the citrus and apple flavors but are followed up by a sweeter fruit on the midpalate, almost like cranberry and cherry juice. I like the balance and vibrancy here. One Star Plus. Importer: Vitis Imports, Inglewood, CA.|
|Domaine de Montbourgeau
Crémant du Jura
|From a great producer in France's Jura, see below and in Issue 2. This is not something you see around very often, but lately more and more Jura wines seem to be showing up in the marketplace. This was actually my first Jura sparkling wine!
Very pretty...floral, baby talc and a hint of yeastiness. Plush and welcoming with a bright Chardonnay fruit that is very approachable yet pretty and refined. The finish is simple but lingers and entices you to take another sip. Quite good and an excellent value for sparkling wine! One Star Plus. Importer: Rosenthal Wine Merchant, New York, NY.
|Ruinart Blanc de Blancs
|For those of you new to Champagne, the wines generally can be made from any combination of three different grape varieties. The only white is Chardonnay. The reds include Pinot Noir and Pinot Meunier. While most wines are some blend of the three, some producers make single color or variety wines. If the wine is made only from red (black) grapes it is called a Blanc de Noirs, basically a "white wine from black grapes". If only white grapes, Chardonnay, are used, it is called a Blanc de Blanc, like this one and the previous wine as well. It is a non-vintage (NV) meaning it is a blend of several vintages.
This one has a bready aroma not unlike buttered matzoh, if you know what I mean. Yeasty flavors that are crisp and refreshing with a nice core of body. It lacks a bit of depth on the mid-palate and doesn't have the depth and breath of flavor I'd hope for. This is nice, but not better, and not a particularly good value at this price. One Star. Importer: Moët Hennessy USA Inc., New York, NY.
Côtes du Jura Tradition
|In Issue 2 and above I've introduced you to other wines from France's Jura. The region, to the east near the Swiss border, produces many interesting wines. Best known for Vin Jaune, aged 6 years in barrel under a layer of flor (yeast), the best of these can be a bit expensive. But some of these lower level wines can be really unique and interesting as well. Check out the two Montbourgeau in this issue as well. This producer, one of the region's best, makes this wine from a blend of Savagnin and Chardonnay.
These can be a bit of an acquired taste (although which wine isn't at the beginning?) because of the hint of oxidation that they acquire as they age. Pretty nuts, grass, chalk, hay and dried apricot aromas open up to a fruity wine that is quite approachable. Bright and eye opening flavors. The fruit is more vibrant and sweet (in ripeness, not residual sugar) than I expected. White grapes, gooseberry, grass, limestone and chalk. All these things are there but all very well tied together, fresh, balanced and lively. A flirtatious wine but still poised and elegant. Great Jura wine. Two Stars. Importer: Martine's Wines, Inc, Novato, CA.
|Jean-Louis Chave Crozes-Hermitage
|Chave is one of the gods of wine-making. His best wines, red and white Hermitage from France's Northern Rhone Valley, can be amongst the worlds best. Elegant, complex, long-lived and simply beautiful. They are also quite expensive. Well he also makes several wines from "lesser" appellations which don't have the prestige of Hermitage but can be very good for much less money. His St. Joseph, Cotes du Rhone and Crozes-Hermitage, all from other Northern Rhone regions, can all be excellent. This one is a white from Crozes-Hermitage which is mostly Marsanne.
This one had me a bit perplexed. I expected a bit more complexity from a Chave, this had a very hesitant nose, just showing a bit of nuttiness. Quite shy. The flavors are soft and mellow, again with some round nuttiness. Just a hint of acid and minerality give it good focus. For now, this is good, but not better. Marsanne can be somewhat foresquare when young so maybe this just needs a bit of time to unfold. One Star (for now). Importer: Langdon Shiverick Inc., Cleveland, OH.
Bodegas Herederos de Argüeso
|Having enjoyed and reviewed the Fino Sherry from the same estate but a different bodega in a previous issue I was eager to try this Manzanilla Pasada. This one has a dry, astringent nose, almost like grapefruit seed with only a hint of Sherry nuttiness. Tart and slightly bitter with grapefruit and nectarine flavors backed up by sunflower and almond richness. This is pretty but somewhat simple. Not as complete and striking as the Fino but this is nevertheless a tasty Sherry and a good value. One Star. Importer: MHW Ltd, Manhasset, NY.|
|Domaine de Montbourgeau
|I introduced you to this fascinating wine from the Jura in Issue 2. Made mostly from Chardonnay, this is aged in barrels with a layer of flor (yeast) that develops on top, giving them a slightly Sherry-like flavor with mild oxidation. Apparently the influence of this flor can vary quite a bit from vintage to vintage. While the 2004 reviewed in Issue 2 was big, nutty and rich, this one is more subtle and less oxidized.
More hesitant but very pretty aromas of flowers, talc, rose petal and a hint of nuttiness. Silky and refined, not as powerful and full-bodied as the 2004, this is more light on its feet, ethereal almost. Like a very light fino Sherry. Pretty lingering gentle finish. Opened up with air and got more expressive. This is very pretty but in a very different way than the 2004. They are each unique. Two Stars. Importer: Rosenthal Wine Merchant, New York, NY.
Montagne d'Alaric 2007
Vin de Pays de Hauterive
|This is a nice cheapie rosé for immediate drinking. Fresh ripe strawberry aromas and flavors are ripe and round but balanced nicely by a slight herbiness that gives it lift and complexity. Easy and tasty. One Star. Importer: Acadia Imports, Santa Rosa, CA.|
|La Vieille Ferme
Côtes du Ventoux 2007
Rhone Valley Vineyards
|Here's an even cheaper rosé from the south of France. Made from 50% Cinsault, 40% Grenache and 10% Syrah. This is saltier with sea brine and southern French herbs for complexity. More acidic and bright with brambly, wild red fruits. More focused and bright. Another excellent quaffer that is good a bit chilled alone or with food. One Star. Importer: Vineyard Brands, Birmingham, AL.|
Saint-Joseph Offerus 2004
|I introduced you to Chave up above with their white Crozes-Hermitage. This is from another Northern Rhone appellation called St. Joseph. The wine is 100% Syrah.
This has reglisse (black licorice) up the wazzoo with a bit of meat and fennel as well. Spicey black fruits, granite minerality, smokey meat and smokey herbs and spices. This is quite nice and definitely speaks of both St. Joseph as well as classic French Syrah. One Star Plus. Importer: Langdon Shiverick Inc., Cleveland, OH.
|Ciù Ciù Oppîdum
Marche Rosso 2002
|Another excellent Italian producer making all organic wines, Ciù Ciù makes several interesting wines from Italy's Marche region.
This starts out with an aroma that I can only compare to peppered meat. Also something smokey like rosemary sizzling on the grill, yet through it all peaks some nice ripe, tangy blueberry and raspberry. In the mouth this quite surprised me. Super velvet! I wasn't expecting something this polished and textured. Pimp-like velvet with a bit of meanness with personality and bite. Rich, black, great with a big grilled Porterhouse, standing up nicely to the rich flavors of the prime meat. Almost Syrah-like pepper, spice, bacon and meat on the lingering finish. Liked this a lot! Two Stars. Importer: Vitis Imports, Inglewood, CA.
|Martilde Tina Barbera
Provincia di Pavia
|This producer in the north of Italy makes several interesting wines from local grapes including several Bonarda, Barbera and blends of the two. The wine-making couple does everything organically and the pretty labels feature animals from around the farm that she painted.
Barbera is a great northern Italian grape that is really traditionally meant to be bright and food-friendly. More modern producers have tried to doctor it up, making it more extracted and covered in toasty oak. While these big, flashy wines often get better scores by critics and in blind tastings, they lack personality and are not as food-friendly. I like the traditionally styled Barbera like this, spicey, herby and brambly aromas. Wild. Bright and acidic flavors with chewy berry fruit like a Barbera should be. This is natural and tastes great. Perfect pizza and pasta wine. One Star Plus. Importer: Vitis Imports, Santa Monica, CA.
|This is a Bordeaux from Graves. While most red Graves are dominated by Cabernet Sauvignon, this one is mostly Merlot.
I usually look for a nice gravely minerality to a classic Graves. This was definitely not classic in the traditional sense. This was decidedly more modern in style with an oak inflected nose of smokey charcoal, coffee, ripe cherry and hint of graphite. The flavors are somewhat forward with rich cherry and chocolate flavors with a plush, polished texture. Definitely a very nice wine with excellent fruit and texture, just a bit flashy and modern for my tastes ideally. Not as much unique, terroir-driven character, but its a good value if you like ripe, powerful Bordeaux. One Star. Importer: Liquid Link, LLC, Palos Verdes Estates, CA.
|OK, well this one isn't cheap either. But let me tell you a little something about Amarone. Coming from Italy's Veneto region, the grapes that make these wines are laid out on mats to air dry, basically becoming raisins, for weeks or months! They are only then fermented and pressed, creating a very concentrated, powerful wine with intense aromas and flavors. Now, good Amarone can be quite expensive. Some of the very best and most popular producers like Quintarelli and Dal Forno can be many hundreds of dollars a bottle. Even poor versions, because of its painstaking process and demand, can be quite pricey, often soaring over $100 a bottle. So when you find an outstanding Amarone for under $100, it seems like a bargain! This producer is just such a case. Their regular bottling, of which I have also had and would probably rate, by memory, One Star Plus to Two Stars, is under $40. This one is a single vineyard version which is generally their top bottling although they do make a Riserva in the best vintages.
This is a deep nose! Tarry, sappy and with tons of spicy complexity. Very dark and deep, you can get lost in there! The flavors are no different, dense, velvety and many layers of fruit, ripe tannins and a powerful core of minerals. This is young but already a showstopper! Two Stars Plus. Importer: Vitis Imports, Inglewood, CA.
Niagra Peninsula 2006
|Several producers in Canada are now making some interesting Icewine, this one from the Niagra Peninsula. Icewine, traditionally Eiswein in Germany, is made from late-harvested grapes that freeze on the vine and are then pressed. The ice crystals are filtered out and you are left with a very concentrated, almost syrupy, sweet wine. While the best Eiswein produced in Germany maintain a high level of acidity and thus age a very long time, these Canadian versions are a bit more forward and are best drunk up young.
A bit of botrytis frames a flirty nose of butterscotch, creme brulée, fruit cake and papaya preserves. Super sweet, honeyed, rich, viscous and opulent. Not quite cloyingly sweet but not particularly structured as the acidity is quite low. No hard edges and the flavors are quite nice. This is actually quite good for a domestic Icewine. A good cheap dessert wine for someone who just wants some thing sweet, sticky and tasty. Of note, these are bottled in tiny 187 mL bottles, only about enough for two small pours. One Star.
© 2008 Poor Man's Guide to Fine Wine. All Rights Reserved.
Search This Site